A regulator unconvinced by the chilling-effect argument
Asked by senators whether the law would have a chilling effect on free speech, Inman Grant was blunt. She said that, particularly over the past two years, she had seen nothing to suggest platforms were removing too much content. On the contrary, she argued, companies are trying to show users as much material as possible, however harmful or hurtful it may be to the Australian community.
“I haven't seen any indication … that companies are over-censoring.” — Julie Inman Grant
In her view, most cases of excessive content removal stem from automated moderation systems running without human oversight, not from regulatory pressure. The real driver of platform behaviour, she suggested, is a business model built on engagement, which rewards keeping content online rather than taking it down.
Big Tech's warnings
The industry painted a very different picture at the hearings on Monday. A senior Google executive in Australia said a provision requiring age checks wherever there is a risk of children seeing pornography could force the company to block under-18s from using Gmail, one of the world's most widely used email services.















