MAIN CONTENT
Tracing the reported payments
Investigations by The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age described recurring transfers of roughly $50,000 a month from a Packer-controlled business to Hadad Roth Shenhar & Co. Their reported total exceeded $1.25 million. Haaretz subsequently said Israeli law enforcement had known of the transactions for months without opening an investigation, according to people familiar with the matter.
The chronology has amplified scrutiny: payments reportedly began in September 2024, shortly after prosecutors finished presenting their case. Yet proximity in time is not proof of an unlawful arrangement. Contracts, invoices, records of legal work and testimony would be necessary to identify what the money purchased and whether any portion supported someone other than the stated client.
A distinction between suspicion and proof
Hadad represents Netanyahu across proceedings commonly called Cases 1000, 2000 and 4000. Packer, whose past gifts to the Netanyahu family feature in Case 1000, is not accused of a crime in that gifts prosecution.
He is relevant as a witness, making the relationship between his finances and the defense lawyer worthy of scrutiny but not automatically improper.
Associates of Packer have said his payments covered representation on matters unconnected to Netanyahu, including business or investment-related work. The original Australian reporting expressly did not establish that Netanyahu received a benefit. That limitation matters: the existence of a commercial relationship cannot, without further evidence, be turned into a finding that the witness financed the prime minister’s legal costs.
The challenge for an impartial trial
A witness paying substantial fees to counsel for a defendant presents questions about potential conflicts, disclosure and independence. Whether any ethical or legal rule was breached depends on the engagements involved, the actual services rendered and Israeli law. Neither the size of a retainer nor political controversy is a substitute for a fact-based inquiry.
Hadad has asked the Jerusalem District Court to permit Packer to testify remotely, saying that he separately represents the billionaire in matters unrelated to the trial. That raises practical questions about witness examination and the opportunity to challenge evidence. A transparent response would examine the underlying records while preserving attorney-client protections and all parties’ procedural rights.
Why public trust is at stake
Case 1000 alleges Netanyahu and his wife accepted valuable cigars, champagne and other benefits from Packer and Hollywood producer Arnon Milchan. The prosecution brought fraud and breach-of-trust allegations in that case. Netanyahu has maintained that the gifts were gestures of friendship, rejected wrongdoing and contested the broader corruption accusations.
The public deserves a credible account of financial arrangements surrounding a nationally consequential trial. Equally, a legal system must not treat an allegation as a verdict. An independent inquiry, if warranted, could distinguish legitimate private services from conflicts requiring remedies or any actual violation. That distinction is the measure of both fairness and accountability.















