A lawsuit that shook an Ivy League school

According to the complaint filed in New York state court in September, Jane Doe, then 20, says she was coerced into taking drugs and then sexually assaulted at the Chi Phi house in Ithaca in October 2024. Campus police made no arrests and the Tompkins County district attorney declined to bring charges. She left Cornell and turned to a civil suit against the seven men, the Chi Phi fraternity and the university.

According to The New York Times, all seven men deny wrongdoing: four say the contact was consensual, and the other three deny taking part. A lawyer for one defendant called the lawsuit a “money grab”. Cornell says it suspended the chapter and expelled or suspended several students, while Doe’s lawyer maintains that only two of the seven were expelled.

Stories that feel “copied and pasted”

Reading the lawsuit, Jane Wang, a 19-year-old student whose family immigrated to the US from China, felt she was reading her own experience. She had reported a sexual assault despite fearing for her scholarship. Six months later, she says, the university’s Title IX office was still promising to contact her when it could. Worn down by the wait, she withdrew her complaint.

The loss of trust is not merely personal. A survey by the student newspaper The Cornell Daily Sun found that only 5% of students trust the university to handle sexual assault reports fairly. Wang argues that such cases cannot be treated as urgent only when Cornell’s reputation is at stake.