MAIN CONTENT

Oil shocks no longer look like the 1970s

For much of modern U.S. history, an oil shock had a familiar meaning: a larger import bill, faster inflation and weaker economic activity. NBER Working Paper 35864 by Diego R. Känzig, James H. Stock and Luca Zanotti finds that relationship changed materially after 2010. The shale boom shifted the U.S. petroleum trade balance from deep deficit toward surplus, so the same global supply shock now creates a different national income effect.

The authors find that before the shale era, oil supply shocks typically raised unemployment and weakened industrial production. Under the newer structure, activity can improve instead. The mechanism is not merely that the United States exports more barrels. Higher oil prices also improve the relative price of what America sells to the world compared with what it buys - an improvement in the terms of trade that can support profits, wealth and spending.

Higher pump prices coexist with larger energy income

EIA data show that in 2025 the United States exported roughly 10.8 million barrels per day of crude oil and petroleum products, while the country’s overall energy trade balance reached record net-export territory. That creates an unusually sharp split inside the economy: fuel-intensive households and businesses lose when prices jump, while producers, refiners and energy-heavy states gain from stronger revenue.