A report that exposes the warning signs
While stressing that determining whether bid-rigging occurred lay outside its remit, the independent committee said the renovation project at Wang Fuk Court had numerous features bearing clear hallmarks of bid-rigging and anticompetitive conduct. The signs it cited included:
- An abnormally low consultancy bid.
- An overly expansive scope of works, with one contractor winning an inflated construction contract.
- An inspector at the estate who existed in name only.
- A seriously misleading tender analysis report.
- Proxy votes concentrated to control critical appointments.
The report warned that such misconduct may involve many parties, some of them linked to triads, and urged society to seize the moment to rebuild a healthy environment for the building maintenance industry:
*“Such a corrupt ecosystem can no longer be tolerated.” — Independent committee report*
From competition breach to criminal offence
According to Secretary for Justice Paul Lam Ting-kwok, the government will amend the Competition Ordinance to criminalise bid-rigging in major building maintenance and renovation projects. The new offence will cover preliminary works, consultancy services and other serious anticompetitive conduct such as price-fixing and market sharing.















