Thirty years of a single market

In 1996 the European Union (EU) laid the foundation for a major reform with two aims: to end state monopolies by exposing public operators such as France’s EDF to private competition, and to unify and interconnect grids across the continent to diversify and stabilise supply. According to Le Monde, the market now brings together 32 countries: the 27 EU members plus Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein, Switzerland and the United Kingdom.

It can be seen as a descendant of the European Coal and Steel Community, the single coal market created in 1952. Physically, interconnected grids allow electricity to flow easily across borders. Because consumption patterns vary from country to country, peaks and troughs can offset each other: in winter, for example, southern Europe has a late peak between 8pm and 10pm, while in the Nordic countries it usually comes around 5pm.

Marginal pricing: the root of the dispute

On short-term wholesale markets, electricity prices follow the marginal pricing principle: the price is set by the most expensive plant needed to meet demand, which is often gas-fired. The mechanism has several features:

  • Advantage: power flows automatically from low-price to high-price areas, optimising generation across the continent; one analysis estimates efficiency gains of about €34 billion a year.